Skip to Content

50 Disney Fish Extender Gifts from Etsy

Taking part in a Disney Cruise Fish Extender Exchange takes a little bit of planning and preparing, but it can be a great way to add a little extra excitement to your cruise! Wondering what types of things people give as Disney Cruise Fish Extender gifts?

Disney Fish Extender Gifts

Great Disney Fish Extender Gifts You Can Purchase on Etsy

If you really would like a handmade gift but don’t have the time to do it yourself, consider Etsy.  Etsy has a great variety of specialty items and all you have to do is a simple search for “Disney Fish Exchange Gifts” and you will find thousands of idea. 

Wondering which ones we love? We’ve compiled a list of 50 different items that you can purchase on Etsy!

50 Disney Fish Extender Gifts You Can Buy on Etsy

If you are looking for ideas for Disney Cruise Fish Extender gifts, this list is perfect.

Nothing to make yourself! You can buy them all in one place in bulk!

As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Choosing the Best Gifts for Each Person

The key is to find gifts that fit each particular person. What I mean by that is that you want to make sure you give a gift that is appropriate based on age & gender.

When you join your Fish Extender exchange group, you will receive a list of names, ages, and room numbers. Some groups even list your favorite Disney character.

Try your best to keep all of that in mind when preparing your gifts.

Don’t feel like your items have to be Disney related.

Some of the best gifts we’ve received were either things that were personalized with our name or things specific to that person’s home state or country (okay, the Vegemite might have not been my favorite).

The point is, no matter what you choose to give, I am sure it will be appreciated.

At the end of the day, it’s the thought that counts!

Looking for Fish Extender gifts you can get quickly? Check out what you can find on Amazon.

What other ideas do you have for Disney Fish Extender Gifts?


Thursday 11th of August 2016

Hi...I've thought about participating in the fish extender fun in previous trips, but I'm still unclear on how you know what to give, how much to give and how often to give (daily, once during trip, couple times). Do you give to each member or family as a whole? Any information would be appreciated. Thank you! :)


Friday 12th of August 2016

We give one gift per person that usually under $3. We figured that it is worth the investment because we walk away with so many neat things and our kids really enjoy the magic of having secret gifts delivered to our room almost daily.


Monday 4th of January 2016

How do you find a fish extender group to join? Haven't been able to find one for me cruise! Help!


Thursday 7th of January 2016

Have you checked out the DIS Board? They should have one already started if you are less than 6 months out. If longer, you may need to wait. I am 100% positive there will be one for your cruise.

DISCLAIMER: Disney Insider Tips is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to and its affiliated international sites. You'll also notice that we do link out to recommended hotels/tours/products/services. If you purchase anything through these links, we often receive a commission. This fee supports our site and allows us to bring you the best Disney insider tips! Read our Privacy Policy